When I first purchased this mask it was a very liquid formulation that a lot of people seem to dislike. However I found that there was no problem with the mask, just the way that it was packaged. I was a little nervous when it turned out the mask had been were formulated in response to feedback from customers, but it is not as heavy as the Moon Velvet sleeping mask which I do not care for (the kind in the tub, I mean). However I was pleasantly surprised that while this mask is much creamier, it does not feel too heavy going on and it does not leave me feeling greasy at all. In the morning my face is always bright and pleasantly hydrated after I use this mask. Really the only downside is that it is pretty expensive when I pay full price, so I only use it a couple times a week. It truly does work well though; whenever I see myself in the mirror after a night of having this mask on, I'm always struck by how bright and clear my skin is. It actually stops me in my tracks and makes me feel guilty for being vain. Lol. While it is beautiful I wish the packaging was less wasteful. There's a lot of extra plastic bulking up the perceived size of the product. It would be excusable if I could refill the pretty tub, but alas, no refill option.